CSA S6 vs AASHTO LRFD: what changes in a bridge estimator's quantities
CSA S6 and AASHTO LRFD do not change how a bridge is taken off. They change the drawings you take off from. This guide by Mirage Metrics follows each difference to the quantity it moves. The live load model sizes girders, strands, bearings and piers: S6's CL-625, which Ontario replaces with CL-625-ONT and British Columbia with CL-800, against AASHTO's HL-93 and state permit vehicles. Each owner's durability rules set the deck. Ontario and British Columbia build 225 mm decks, Ontario with 70 mm of top cover under a waterproofing membrane, while Texas builds 8.5 in decks with 2.5 in of top cover. Barrier test levels set the parapets. Units set the bar list, and CSA G30.18 bars (10M to 55M) have no exact ASTM A615 equivalent (#3 to #18). S6:25 and the AASHTO 10th edition are current, but owners adopt editions late and with supplements, so read the edition on the drawings.
- Published
- Updated
- Reading time
- 13 min
- Written by
- Jules Toussaint
This page is descriptive, not design advice. CSA S6 and AASHTO LRFD are paywalled, so their provisions are described from the owners' manuals that adopt them (MTO, BC, TxDOT, Caltrans), the federal regulation, the publishers' announcements and published papers, as read on 9 November 2026.
Who wrote this, and why. Mirage Metrics builds AI agents that read construction documents, including plan sets drawn in metric or imperial units and documents in English or French. Mirage has no published deployment on a bridge designed to either code, so this page is reference material built from the owners' own documents. Its nearest published proofs are in quantity work. At OCBM, three agents are in production and 100% of quantities are tied to a source drawing. At John Cockerill, the result is 80 to 90% less time on piping takeoff.
Editions in force, and who adopts which
CSA Group released CSA S6:25, the 13th edition of the Canadian Highway Bridge Design Code, at the end of 2025. It is the first edition to use predictive modelling for future climate risks (Construction Canada, 1 December 2025). AASHTO issued the 10th edition of its LRFD Bridge Design Specifications in December 2024, with extensive revisions to Section 3 (loads and load factors), Section 5 (concrete) and Section 6 (steel) (AASHTO Journal, 20 December 2024).
Neither date tells you what a given bridge was designed to. An owner adopts a code through its own manual, which deletes, replaces and adds clauses, and moves to a new edition on its own schedule. The federal regulation shows the lag: 23 CFR 625.4 still incorporates the 8th Edition of 2017. The standards it lists govern the National Highway System, while other federal-aid projects follow State standards (23 CFR 625.3(a) and 625.4(d)(1)(v)).
| Owner | Code and edition its documents name | Design live load it requires | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ontario (MTO) | CSA S6-25 with MTO's exceptions (Structural Manual, draft of December 2025) | CL-625-ONT truck and lane load in every clause | MTO draft, Div. 1, 3.8.3.1.2 and 3.8.3.1.3 |
| British Columbia (MoTT) | CSA S6:19 with the Ministry's Supplement of February 2025 | CL-800, plus special loads EPLL1 and EPLL2 on named routes | BC Supplement, 3.8.3.1.1 and 3.8.3.2.3 |
| Alberta | CSA S6 | CL-800 | Pushka et al. 2021 |
| Manitoba | AASHTO LRFD with Manitoba's amended Structures Design Manual | HL-93 and a Modified HSS-25 truck | Pushka et al. 2021 |
| US federal-aid (FHWA) | 8th Edition (2017), incorporated in 23 CFR 625.4 for the NHS; other federal-aid work follows State standards | Not set in the regulation | 23 CFR 625.3(a), 625.4(d)(1)(v) |
| Texas (TxDOT) | AASHTO LRFD, 2020, 9th Edition (Bridge Design Manual, September 2024) | HL-93 | TxDOT BDM, Chapter 1 |
| California (Caltrans) | AASHTO LRFD with California's amendments (cited as CA articles) | HL-93 (Strength I) and the P15 permit vehicle (Strength II) | Caltrans BDP 3.4.1 |
So a bridge let by British Columbia under its February 2025 supplement is designed to S6:19, not S6:25 (BC Supplement, preface). A Texas bridge is designed to the 9th edition, through TxDOT's manual (TxDOT BDM, Chapter 1). Manitoba catches cross-border bidders the other way, because it specifies AASHTO, not S6, for its provincial highway bridges (Pushka et al. 2021). Before you price, read the edition and supplement in the design criteria or general notes.
Live loads: CL-625 and its provincial variants against HL-93
CL-625 is the minimum live load model S6 specifies, and provinces raise it to suit their trucks. British Columbia, Alberta and Ontario each specify a heavier variant (Pushka et al. 2021). Ontario's exceptions replace the CL-625 truck and lane load with CL-625-ONT "in all the clauses of the Code", and they allow the owner to specify a loading above it (MTO draft, 3.8.3.1). British Columbia now designs for CL-800, which it raised from BCL-625 because permit overloads were approaching 80 tonnes gross (BC Supplement, 3.8.3.1). In S6, the lane load is a portion of the design truck combined with a uniformly distributed load (Buckland & Taylor 2004).
| Model | Where it applies | Configuration as published | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| CL-625 | CSA S6, the minimum model | The CL-W truck and lane load at W = 625 kN; tandem of two 125 kN axles 1.2 m apart, 600 by 250 mm wheel footprints | Pushka et al.; MTO draft 3.8.3.1; Finlay et al. |
| CL-625-ONT | Ontario | Same family; 140 kN on each tandem axle; replaces the CL-625 truck and lane load | Finlay et al.; MTO draft 3.8.3.1.2 |
| CL-800 | British Columbia, Alberta | Raised from BCL-625 in BC as permit overloads approached 80 t gross | BC Supplement 3.8.3.1.2 commentary |
| HL-93 | AASHTO LRFD | Truck of 8, 32 and 32 kips (35.6, 142.3, 142.3 kN), 14 ft then 14 to 30 ft (4.27 m, 4.27 to 9.14 m), or tandem of two 25-kip axles 4 ft apart; plus 640 lb/ft (9.3 kN/m) lane load | Caltrans BDP 3.4.1; Pushka et al., Figure 1 |
Load factors and dynamic allowance, at the level an estimator needs
AASHTO's Strength I limit state factors component dead load by 1.25, the wearing surface by 1.50, and live load with its dynamic allowance by 1.75 (Pushka et al., Equation 2, citing AASHTO 2020). The allowance is 33% on the truck or tandem and nothing on the lane load (Caltrans BDP 3.4.2). S6's design live load factor is 1.70. Its dynamic load allowance depends on the axles that govern: 0.40 for a single axle group (Buckland & Taylor 2004), and on a buried structure from 0.40 at the surface down to 0.10 under 1.5 m of cover (Finlay et al. 2003). States add their own vehicles too. California checks its P15 permit truck in Strength II, which governs most superstructure elements in Caltrans's worked example (BDP 3.4.1.2).
None of these numbers enters a takeoff. They decide girder depth and spacing, strand counts, steel tonnage, bearings and piers before the drawings reach you. That is why a Canadian and an American design of the same crossing are two bridges, not one bridge in two units. What an estimator can do is read which model governed. A provincial truck, a permit vehicle or a special load such as BC's EPLL1 and EPLL2 (3.8.3.2.3) explains a superstructure heavier than its span suggests.
The quantity table: what moves, and where to check it
This table shows where the two codes reach your quantities. Its rows compare owners, not code minimums, because what reaches a bid is the code as each owner adopted it. The caption names the four manuals.
| Item | Under S6 (Canadian owners) | Under AASHTO LRFD (US owners) | Effect on the quantity | Where the estimator checks it |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Deck slab thickness | Ontario: a standard 225 mm deck. BC: not less than 225 mm (8.18.2) | Texas: 8.5 in standard, thinner decks not permitted | Deck concrete of 0.225 m³/m² against 0.216 m³/m², about 4% more | Deck section, general notes |
| Top and bottom cover | Ontario: deck top 70 ± 20 mm, bottom 40 ± 10 mm. BC: 50 to 70 mm by bar type and membrane | Texas: 2.5 in (64 mm) top, 1.25 in (32 mm) bottom | Mat positions, bar supports, stirrup heights; the bar size and spacing that compensate are the designer's | General notes, clear cover |
| Deck reinforcement type | Ontario: Grade 500W; stainless (S prefix) or GFRP (G prefix) where specified; no epoxy coating. BC: top mat protected by bar type, membrane or both; stainless on main roads | Texas: Grade 60; epoxy-coated, galvanized, GFRP, ASTM A1035 or stainless where the district requires | Same mass per bar size, different unit price; the bar list splits by material | Reinforcing steel notes, bar marks, bar list |
| Deck protection | Ontario: asphalt waterproofing with protection board, then asphalt paving; exposed decks only with premium bars. BC: membrane optional, traded against cover and bar type | Texas: Class S concrete, high performance where the district requires it for de-icing agents or salt spray | Membrane and paving areas, or none; the concrete class changes the price, not the volume | Deck details, paving notes, special provisions |
| Girders, strands, bearings, piers | CL-625, CL-625-ONT or CL-800; live load factor 1.70 | HL-93 (with P15 in California); factor 1.75 in Strength I | Fixed by the design: depth, count and tonnage are not takeoff choices | Design criteria, general notes |
| Barriers | CHBDC test levels TL-1 to TL-5, with exposure limits in CHBDC Table 12.5. BC: TL-4 F-shape standard parapet; a 1070 mm TL-5 barrier | MASH test levels: TL-4 most of the time at Caltrans; MASH TL-5 rails at TxDOT where piers need protection | Parapet concrete and bars per metre, plus overhang reinforcement for the barrier loads | Barrier standard drawing named on the plans |
| Units and bar names | SI: mm, kg; bars 10M to 55M (CSA G30.18) | US customary: in, lb; bars #3 to #18 (ASTM A615), sometimes soft-metric #10 to #57 | Mass per metre differs for almost every pair; no exact equivalents | Bar list header, general notes |
Durability is where owners differ most
The deck rows carry the largest differences an estimator can see. MTO protects decks with an asphalt waterproofing system and protection board under asphalt paving, and it uses Premium Reinforcement in salt-susceptible areas. It no longer uses epoxy-coated bars, which studies found added no corrosion protection. Its studies of decks built in the early 1980s found that membrane and cover gave a 75-year service life, provided the waterproofing is replaced every 30 years (MTO draft, Division 2, 2.4.8). Where premium bars are specified, its general notes call for stainless bars of Type 316LN, Duplex 2205 or 2304.
British Columbia makes the trade explicit. Every deck is at least 225 mm thick, and a table sets the top cover from the top mat's bar type and the presence of a membrane. The cover is 60 mm for stainless on main roads without a membrane, 50 mm with one, and 70 mm for ASTM A1035 bars without one (Table 8.11.2.5.2). TxDOT leaves the same choice to its districts and keeps stainless for extreme coastal exposure (Chapter 3, Section 2).
Barriers
Both codes now speak of test levels. On low-volume roads MTO allows a TL-0 or TL-1 barrier only within limits of traffic, height above water, design speed and bridge width, and otherwise requires CHBDC TL-2 to TL-5 (Division 1, Section 2, Table 2.4-3). BC's standard bridge parapet is a TL-4 F-shape, with a 1070 mm constant slope barrier approved for TL-5 (Section 12). Caltrans applies TL-4 most of the time and carries the collision forces into the deck overhang (BDP 3.4), so a higher test level adds overhang reinforcement as well as parapet concrete.
Rebar sizes: CSA G30.18 bars against ASTM A615 bars
Canadian drawings name CSA G30.18 bars 10M to 55M. A 10M bar has a nominal area of 100 mm², 15M has 200 mm², and 55M has 2,500 mm². US drawings name bars by number, which is about the diameter in eighths of an inch, or by the soft-metric number, about the diameter in whole millimetres. So #5 is #16, and #9 is #29 (CRSI). Mirage reads plan sets in either system, and no reader should convert one system's bars into the other's.
| CSA bar | Diameter, mm | Area, mm² | Mass, kg/m | Nearest ASTM bar | Area, mm² (in²) | Mass, kg/m (lb/ft) | Mass difference |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 10M | 11.3 | 100 | 0.785 | #3 [#10] or #4 [#13] | 71 (0.11) or 129 (0.20) | 0.560 (0.376) or 0.994 (0.668) | -29% or +27% |
| 15M | 16.0 | 200 | 1.570 | #5 [#16] | 200 (0.31) | 1.552 (1.043) | -1.1% |
| 20M | 19.5 | 300 | 2.355 | #6 [#19] | 284 (0.44) | 2.235 (1.502) | -5.1% |
| 25M | 25.2 | 500 | 3.925 | #8 [#25] | 510 (0.79) | 3.973 (2.670) | +1.2% |
| 30M | 29.9 | 700 | 5.495 | #9 [#29] | 645 (1.00) | 5.060 (3.400) | -7.9% |
| 35M | 35.7 | 1000 | 7.850 | #11 [#36] | 1006 (1.56) | 7.907 (5.313) | +0.7% |
| 45M | 43.7 | 1500 | 11.775 | #14 [#43] | 1452 (2.25) | 11.384 (7.650) | -3.3% |
| 55M | 56.4 | 2500 | 19.625 | #18 [#57] | 2581 (4.00) | 20.239 (13.600) | +3.1% |
Only three pairs come within about 1% in mass: 15M and #5, 25M and #8, 35M and #11 (Russel Metals). 10M sits between #3 and #4, so a bar-for-bar swap either removes 29% of the steel or adds 27%. #7 and #10 have no CSA counterpart: no CSA bar comes close to their area. Grades differ as well: MTO's notes call for Grade 500W, TxDOT's for Grade 60. A substitution moves area, spacing, development length and cover, so it is the engineer's decision, never the takeoff's. In the takeoff, convert lengths and masses exactly and keep the designations the drawings give.
Example: the rebar in one square metre of deck, both ways
Illustrative example, invented figures: the same deck detailed with metric and with US bars
A Canadian drawing details a deck with top and bottom mats of 15M at 200 mm across the deck and 15M at 300 mm along it. A US drawing of a similar deck uses #5 at 8 in and #5 at 12 in. Laps, hooks, bar supports and end cover are ignored.
| Canadian drawing (15M) | US drawing (#5) | |
|---|---|---|
| Bars across the deck, both mats | 15M at 200 mm: 10.00 m per m² | #5 at 8 in: 3.00 ft per ft² (9.84 m per m²) |
| Bars along the deck, both mats | 15M at 300 mm: 6.67 m per m² | #5 at 12 in: 2.00 ft per ft² (6.56 m per m²) |
| Mass of the bar | 1.570 kg/m | 1.043 lb/ft (1.552 kg/m) |
| Reinforcement per unit of deck | 26.17 kg/m² (5.36 lb/ft²) | 5.215 lb/ft² (25.46 kg/m²) |
The metric deck carries 2.8% more steel per square metre: 1.6% from the spacing (200 and 300 mm against 203.2 and 304.8 mm) and 1.2% from the bar's mass per metre. Pricing it with the #5 mass understates it by 1.1%. Reading 10M at 200 mm as #4 at 8 in goes the other way and overstates that layer by 25% (7.85 against 9.78 kg/m² for two mats).
Limits: what this page does not settle
- Not design advice. Covers, bars and loads belong to the engineer of record under the owner's manual. An estimator reads them and never changes them.
- Owner documents move. MTO's manual quoted here is a December 2025 draft for external review, BC's supplement is written to S6:19 and TxDOT's manual to the 9th edition. Check the edition the contract names.
- Evaluation and rehabilitation follow other rules. TxDOT rates new bridges to AASHTO's Manual for Bridge Evaluation (Chapter 5, Section 7). BC amends S6's evaluation clauses separately (14.9).
- Quantities move with the design. On design-build and public-private partnership (P3) work, the quantities of the 30% design are not those of the issued drawings (see the AACE estimate classes guide).
Software can help with reading general notes and bar lists in either unit system, tying each quantity to its drawing, flagging a bar designation that does not belong to the sheet's unit system, and comparing revisions (see plan revision comparison, the quantity takeoff guide and the heavy civil page). A person still decides which edition and supplement govern, whether a substitution is acceptable, and the price.
Questions readers ask
Yes, CSA S6:25 is out, and the current AASHTO LRFD edition is the 10th edition of the LRFD Bridge Design Specifications, issued in December 2024. CSA Group released S6:25, the 13th edition of the Canadian Highway Bridge Design Code, at the end of 2025. Owners adopt editions on their own schedule, though. MTO's December 2025 draft writes its exceptions to S6-25, BC's February 2025 supplement is written to S6:19, TxDOT's September 2024 manual applies the 9th edition, and 23 CFR 625.4 still incorporates the 8th edition of 2017.
CL-625 is the minimum live load model of CSA S6, a design truck and lane load named for 625 kN. Its tandem is two 125 kN axles 1.2 m apart. Ontario's CL-625-ONT carries 140 kN on each of those axles, and MTO's exceptions replace the CL-625 truck and lane load with the CL-625-ONT ones in every clause of the code. British Columbia and Alberta design for CL-800.
HL-93 is the AASHTO LRFD vehicular design load: a 72-kip design truck (8, 32 and 32 kips, the rear axle spacing varying from 14 to 30 ft) or a design tandem of two 25-kip axles 4 ft apart, each combined with a 640 lb/ft design lane load. A 33% dynamic load allowance applies to the truck or tandem but not to the lane load, and the Strength I limit state factors live load by 1.75.
Under CSA G30.18, a 15M bar is about 16 mm in diameter, with a nominal area of 200 mm² and a mass of 1.570 kg/m, and a 10M bar is about 11.3 mm, with 100 mm² and 0.785 kg/m. The nearest US bar to 15M is #5 (0.31 in², 1.043 lb/ft or 1.552 kg/m). 10M falls between #3 and #4, so no US bar replaces it directly.
An estimator can convert a metric bar list to US bar sizes only as a check, never as a substitution. Areas and masses differ for almost every pair (#9 is 7.9% lighter than 30M, and #4 is 27% heavier than 10M). A different bar also changes spacing, development length and cover, which the engineer of record decides.
Sources and scope
Checked on . Every source was read on 9 November 2026. CSA S6 and AASHTO LRFD are not freely available; their provisions are described from the owner documents, the regulation, the publishers' announcements and the papers listed. The worked example is invented.
- Construction Canada, New bridge code addresses future climate risks, 1 December 2025: CSA S6:25 is the 13th edition of the Canadian Highway Bridge Design Code and the first to use predictive modelling for future climate risks
- AASHTO Journal, AASHTO Issues 10th LRFD Bridge Design Spec Edition, 20 December 2024: 10th edition issued; extensive revisions to Section 3 (loads and load factors, risk-targeted design response spectra), Section 5 (concrete) and Section 6 (steel)
- 23 CFR Part 625, Design Standards for Highways, eCFR text up to date as of 5 November 2026 (read 9 November 2026): 625.3(a)(1) NHS standards approved by the Secretary; 625.3(a)(2) other federal-aid projects to State standards; 625.4(b) bridge standards; 625.4(d)(1)(v) LRFD Bridge Design Specifications, 8th Edition, 2017, incorporated by reference
- Ontario Ministry of Transportation, Structural Manual, draft of December 2025 for external review, part 1 (PDF): Division 1 Section 2, Appendix A, Table 2.4-3, barrier selection on low-volume roads (TL-0, TL-1, otherwise CHBDC TL-2 to TL-5); Division 1 Section 1, exceptions to CSA S6-25: 3.8.3.1.2 and 3.8.3.1.3 CL-625-ONT truck and lane load replace CL-W and CL-625 in all clauses, a loading above CL-625 may be specified by the owner, 8.11.2.4.1 cover tolerances; Division 2 Section 2: 2.1.1 design to the CHBDC, 2.4.6 cover, 2.4.8 corrosion protection policy (membrane, Premium Reinforcement, epoxy coating no longer used, 75-year service life with the membrane replaced every 30 years), a standard 225 mm deck, general notes for slab-on-girder bridges (deck top 70 ± 20 mm, bottom 40 ± 10 mm, Grade 500W, stainless and GFRP bar marks)
- BC Ministry of Transportation and Transit, Bridge Standards and Procedures Manual, Volume 1, Supplement to CHBDC S6:19, February 2025 (PDF): 3.8.3.1.1 CL-800 for Ministry bridges, raised from BCL-625; 3.8.3.2.3 special loads EPLL1 and EPLL2; approach slabs; 8.18.2 slab not less than 225 mm; Table 8.11.2.5.2 top mat bar type, top cover and membrane; Section 12 TL-4 F-shape parapet and a 1070 mm TL-5 barrier; 12.4.3.5 commentary, live load factor 1.7 on barrier loads; 14.9.1.1 evaluation
- TxDOT, Bridge Design Manual LRFD, September 2024, Manual Notice 2024-1 effective 10 September 2024 (PDF): Chapter 1: applies the AASHTO LRFD Bridge Design Specifications, 2020, 9th Edition; Chapter 3 Section 2: Class S concrete, Grade 60 reinforcement, corrosion resistant options by district, stainless only for extreme coastal chloride exposure, 8.5 in standard deck, 2.5 in top and 1.25 in bottom clear cover; Chapter 2: MASH Test Level 5 rails for pier protection; Chapter 5, Section 7: load rating new bridges to the AASHTO MBE
- Caltrans, Bridge Design Practice, Chapter 3, Loads and Load Combinations, October 2022 (PDF): 3.4.1 HL-93: 72-kip three-axle design truck with variable rear axle spacing, 25-kip tandem axles 4 ft apart, 640 plf lane load; 3.4.1.2 P15 permit vehicle with Strength II, which governs most superstructure elements in the example; 3.4.2 IM 33 percent, not applied to the lane load; barrier: TL-4 most of the time, forces carried into the overhang and deck
- Pushka, Regehr, Fiorillo, Mufti and Algohi, Reliability analysis of typical highway bridges in Manitoba designed to the Modified HSS-25 live load model, Canadian Journal of Civil Engineering, manuscript cjce-2021-0031.R1, 2021 (repository copy): CL-625 the minimum CHBDC live load model; BCL-625, Alberta's CL-800 and Ontario's CL-625-ONT increase it; Manitoba specifies AASHTO with an amended Structures Design Manual and a Modified HSS-25 truck; Strength I 1.25 DC, 1.5 DW, 1.75 (LL+IM), IM 1.33; Figure 1, HL-93 in SI units; first AASHTO LRFD edition 1994
- Finlay, Biro and Ahmed, Soil-Steel Structures and the Canadian Highway Bridge Design Code, Transportation Association of Canada annual conference, 2003 (PDF): CL-625 tandem of two 125 kN axles 1.2 m apart; CL-625-ONT tandem of two 140 kN axles; 600 by 250 mm wheel footprint; CL-625-ONT for Ontario; buried structures, dynamic load allowance from 0.40 at the surface to 0.10 at 1.5 m of cover
- Buckland & Taylor for the BC Ministry of Forests, Design Vehicle Configuration Analysis and CSA-S6-00 Implication Evaluation, Phase III, 8 October 2004 (PDF): CHBDC design live load factor of 1.7; CHBDC dynamic load allowance of 0.40 for a single axle group; the CHBDC lane load model, a portion of the design vehicle with a uniformly distributed load
- Russel Metals (Acier Leroux), Reinforcing Bars (Rebar), product page (read 9 November 2026): CSA G30.18 Grade 400R or 400W bars 10M to 55M and ASTM A615 Grade 40 or 60 bars #3 to #18: nominal area in mm² and in², mass in kg/m and lb/ft
- CRSI, Reinforced Concrete Terminology (web page, read 9 November 2026): bar number approximately the diameter in eighths of an inch or whole millimetres; #5 [#16], #9 [#29], #3 [#10], #4 to #18 [#13 to #57]
This guide explains public bridge design documents for estimators. It is not engineering advice; the owner's manual, the contract and the engineer of record govern every bridge.
Show us how your estimators read bridge documents
Leave your work email, then pick a time for a 30-minute call on the bridge drawings, bar lists and owner manuals your estimators read by hand, in metric or imperial units. You leave with a written plan: what an agent could prepare and what stays with your team. No commitment.