DOT bid tabs: how to read and use bid tabulations from KYTC, Ohio DOT, LaDOTD, TxDOT and VDOT

A bid tabulation, or bid tab, is the owner's record of a letting. It shows every bidder's unit price and extended amount on every pay item of a contract, beside the engineer's estimate where the owner publishes it. On federal-aid highway work, the state DOT must tabulate at least the item details of the three lowest acceptable bids (23 CFR 635.113). Before award, it also reviews the low bid's unit prices against its estimate for unbalancing (635.114). Estimators read the same tabs as historical unit prices, which they adjust for quantity, location, time and the character of the project. This guide by Mirage Metrics compares where five DOTs post their tabs, pay items and average unit prices: Kentucky, Ohio, Louisiana, Texas and Virginia. It explains the statistics and the federal tests for unbalanced bids, and it gives you a template that flags outlying unit prices and re-ranks bids at your own quantities.

Published
Updated
Reading time
13 min
Written by
Jules Toussaint

Federal rules come from 23 CFR 635 and FHWA's 2021 guidelines. DOT facts come from each owner's own pages and documents as read on 9 November 2026, and Louisiana's from archived copies of its 2026 pages. This is not legal or bidding advice.

Who wrote this, and why. Mirage Metrics builds AI agents that read construction documents: plan sets, specifications and the owner's bid documents. Mirage has no published deployment with a state DOT or on bid tabulations, so this page is reference material built from the owners' own documents. Its nearest published proofs are in quantity work. At OCBM, three agents are in production and 100% of quantities are tied to a source drawing. At John Cockerill, the result is 80 to 90% less time on piping takeoff.

What a bid tabulation contains

A bid tab is easier to use once you know what the owner records in it and why. TxDOT's 2024 specifications define a letting as "the receipt, opening, tabulation, and determination of the apparent low Bidder" (Item 1, 1.3.76). The tabulation is the record of that step, and federal rules set its floor. Bids are opened publicly and read item by item or by total. The DOT also sends FHWA certified tabulations showing item details for at least the low three acceptable bids and the totals of all other acceptable bids (23 CFR 635.113(a) and (b)).

A tab has a header and lines. The header names the contract or call order, the letting date, the county or district, the work type and the number of bidders. At several owners it also carries the engineer's estimate. KYTC prints it with the low bid's percentage from it (KYTC tabs of 22 October 2026). Ohio DOT prints it on the official tabulation and gives each bidder's percentage from the state estimate in its results (Ohio DOT bid results). TxDOT shows its estimate beside the bids (Bid Tabulations dashboard). VDOT, by contrast, keeps the estimates it prepares confidential in perpetuity (VDOT Cost Estimating Manual 3.1). That goes further than FHWA's advice not to disclose an estimate before award (FHWA 2021).

Each line carries the pay item number, its description, the unit, the bid quantity, and each bidder's unit price and extension. Three details trip readers up:

  • The low total is not the low price on each line. VDOT's manual shows a tab where the low bidder was the highest of three on one item (section 4.2).
  • As read is not official. The apparent low bid comes first, and the tabulation is published once the bids are checked. TxDOT makes a project's tab public after its Construction Division has verified the bids (PS&E Manual 5.4.1.1).
  • A tiny unit price may be a zero. TxDOT rounds unit bids to the nearest tenth of a cent, and it tabulates a blank-dollar, zero or sub-$0.001 entry as $0.001. A proposal with a blank unit price, however, is nonresponsive (Item 2, 2.11.3 and 2.11.5).

Bid tabs at KYTC, Ohio DOT, LaDOTD, TxDOT and VDOT

All five owners publish item-level tabs, but each one numbers its pay items, averages its prices and keeps its history differently. The table below sets them side by side. One warning on names: "ODOT" in a search can mean Ohio, Oregon or Oklahoma, and the Ohio DOT column here covers Ohio only.

Where five state DOTs publish bid tabs, pay items and unit prices, as their own pages and documents stated on 9 November 2026 (Louisiana: archived copies of 2026). Compiled by Mirage Metrics, November 2026.
KYTC (Kentucky)Ohio DOTLaDOTD (Louisiana)TxDOT (Texas)VDOT (Virginia)
Standard specifications in forceStandard Specifications for Road and Bridge Construction, Edition of 2026, from the January 2026 lettingConstruction and Material Specifications (C&MS), 2023 Edition, updated twice a yearLouisiana Standard Specifications for Roads and Bridges, 2026 Edition, effective 1 January 2026Standard Specifications for Construction and Maintenance of Highways, Streets, and Bridges, adopted 1 September 2024Road and Bridge Specifications, 2020 edition, from the July 2020 advertisements, with the 2022 Supplement
Pay item numberNumeric item code, description, unit: 2200 Roadway excavation, CUYDC&MS item, a letter, five digits: 202E23000 Pavement removed, SYSection, two digits, five digits: 202-02-02020 Removal of asphalt pavement, SQYD; items kept by spec year (2007 metric, 2016, 2026)Three-digit item plus a four-digit descriptive code: Item 110 with 7001 Excavation (Roadway); special specifications SS plus four digitsSection, type (SD, SP, SX, PA), spec year, sequence: 301SD20-0001 Clearing and grubbing
Bids received throughBid ExpressBid ExpressBid ExpressTxDOT's Electronic Bidding System (iCX)Bid Express online bid form
Results and bid tabsLetting results; bid tabs of awarded projects as one PDF per letting: bidders, engineer's estimate, low bid's percentage from it, every unit priceApparent low bidder report (totals, percentage from the state estimate); official bid tabulation per project in the Digital Paper searchApparent bid results, letting results and bid tabulations by letting date and location, headquarters or districtBid Tabulations dashboard (Tableau): every bid and TxDOT's estimate, statewide and district lettingsAs-read results and one tabulation PDF per letting for awarded projects: unit price and extension by bidder
History onlineLetting PDFs listed back to 25 October 2019PDF tabs by letting date back to 1998; Power BI Bid Tabs reportRecent lettings by date; a list of projects let in the past year24 months on the dashboard; an archive for tabs before January 2025Combined tabulations by year back to 1993 (ZIP); Statewide Bid Tab Query, almost 30 years
Average unit pricesAverage Unit Bid Prices by calendar year, all awarded jobs, 1997 to 2025 (Excel): dollars divided by quantityItem Price Search, Summary of Contracts Awarded, Project Price Profiles (Power BI)Weighted unit price by quarter and last four quarters: bids, quantity, total, minimum, maximum, average (CSV)Bid Item Averages dashboard, 24 months by bid code, updated daily; it replaced the 3-month and 12-month average low bid unit price tables1-year and 2-year statewide and district averages, 3-month district averages, a two-year price history with the award, second and third bids (XLSX)
LettingsMonthly, on a Thursday; federal-aid projects advertised at least 21 days aheadDates on its contracts pages; the letting of 29 October 2026 was a ThursdayHeadquarters lettings, mostly on Wednesdays (three in June 2026), plus district lettingsStatewide letting in Austin on two consecutive days each month, plus district lettingsWednesdays, for example 23 September and 28 October 2026
Where five state DOTs publish bid tabs, pay items and unit prices, as their own pages and documents stated on 9 November 2026 (Louisiana: archived copies of 2026). Compiled by Mirage Metrics, November 2026.

Source: KYTC: CM 25-08, Unit Bid Tabulations, Average Unit Bid Prices, 2028 schedule, Construction Procurement. Ohio: C&MS, bidding, bid data reports, sold projects, tab of 29 October 2026, tab of 24 June 1998. LaDOTD: 2026 LSSRB, letting information, weighted averages. TxDOT: 2024 specifications, PS&E 5.2, contract letting, tabulations, bid items. VDOT: specifications, pay item format, item codes, bidding, tabs of 23 September 2026, cost estimation.

TxDOT bid items: how the codes work

Reading a TxDOT tab starts with its item codes. Every TxDOT standard specification has a three-digit item number (Item 110, Excavation). Each item is then divided into four-digit descriptive codes, one per way of bidding it: a unit of measure, a size or a type. Under Item 110, code 7001 is Excavation (Roadway). Item 247, Flexible Base, has codes 7136 and 7052 for identical material measured and paid differently, so choosing the wrong code changes the payment, not the work. Special specifications carry four digits after the prefix SS, as in SS1004, Tree Protection (PS&E Manual 5.2.1 and 5.2.2). TxDOT's bid item index and the abbreviations of its code descriptions are on its Bid Items and Index page.

What each average actually averages

The averages are not interchangeable. KYTC's yearly file covers all awarded jobs (595 contracts in 2025). Its average price works out to the item's dollars divided by its quantity, which means large quantities weigh more. Roadway excavation, for example, totals 3,262,198 CUYD for about $50.5 million and averages $15.47 (KYTC 2025 workbook). LaDOTD publishes a weighted unit price by quarter and over the last four quarters, with the number of bids, the minimum and the maximum (Weighted Averages). VDOT's statewide file gives a minimum, maximum and average per item. Its two-year history lists the award price with the second and third bids by region and quarter (Items codes). TxDOT compiles its averages once the Commission has awarded the low bids (5.4.1.2). Read the column headings before you mix two owners' figures.

How estimators use bid tabs

For an estimator, a bid tab is a source of unit prices, and the owners' own manuals say how to adjust them. FHWA calls this the historical bid-based technique. Plan quantities are priced from historical unit bid prices, "adjusted for project conditions (i.e., project location, size, quantities, etc.) and the general market conditions" (FHWA 2021). TxDOT tells its designers that previous bid prices or average low bid prices are only a starting point. It then lists what moves them, starting with project size ("projects with large quantities will tend to have lower unit bid prices"), then location, traffic, construction season and access (PS&E Manual 5.4.1.3). VDOT's manual turns the idea into five filters, to be applied a few at a time so the sample does not vanish (section 4.2, Table 4-2):

  • Geography. Stay in the district, or the nearest one with similar ground and haul distances.
  • Quantity. Unit prices fall as quantities grow, because fixed costs spread. In VDOT's Lynchburg district, borrow excavation averaged $38.20 per CY at 1,000 to 9,000 CY and $14.86 at 10,000 to 50,000 CY. Pricing 5,000 CY from the larger range would therefore understate the item by $116,700 (Table 4-3).
  • Unit of measure. The same description can exist in two units, such as dry riprap by SY and by ton. Match item codes, not words.
  • Time. Index old prices with FHWA's National Highway Construction Cost Index (NHCCI), using the ratio of today's index to the index at the bid date. The index can fall as well as rise.
  • Project character. Check whether the work is urban or rural, at night, staged, near rail or water, in rock or soil. A turn lane does not price a bridge replacement.

Which statistic, and which bids

Ways to turn a set of bid tab prices into one unit price, after VDOT's Cost Estimating Manual 3.1, section 4.3. Compiled by Mirage Metrics, November 2026.
MethodWhat it computesWhat it does to the estimate
Simple averageEvery unit price counts once, whatever its quantityUnderestimates small quantities and overestimates large ones
Weighted averageSum of quantity times price over the sum of quantitiesStill underestimates small quantities; VDOT says it is rarely used correctly
Nonlinear regressionA curve of unit price against quantityFollows the economy of scale; read it with the scatter plot
Lowest price on each lineThe minimum across bidders, line by lineTotals below the actual low bid, since bidders place costs in different items
Low bidder's pricesThe awarded bid's unit pricesVDOT keeps it for analyzing work orders, not for estimates
Three lowest biddersAverage of the three lowest bids on each lineTends to exceed the low bid; VDOT's choice for estimating future projects
Ways to turn a set of bid tab prices into one unit price, after VDOT's Cost Estimating Manual 3.1, section 4.3. Compiled by Mirage Metrics, November 2026.

VDOT's manual gives a worked example. Five prices of $125, $110, $105, $95 and $75, for 50, 75, 100, 500 and 1,000 units, average $102.00, but only $85.51 when weighted by quantity (Table 4-6). Because bidders allocate costs differently among items, an estimate built from the lowest price on every line falls below the actual low bid. The average of the three lowest bidders, by contrast, tends to sit above it. The manual keeps the low bidder's own prices for analyzing work orders, and the three-bidder average for estimating future projects.

Outliers are removed by rule, not by eye. The pricing models VDOT loads into AASHTOWare Project Estimation use the top three bidders, the last 24 months and items with at least 30 data points. They price by district, remove the 10% outliers and keep no model in which cost rises with quantity. The software also warns when a quantity falls outside the range a model was built on (Appendix C). VDOT's Statewide Bid Tab Query holds almost 30 years of design-bid-build bids and adds scatter plots and NHCCI indexing (VDOT cost estimation).

FHWA also describes a combined technique. Most projects carry a small number of items that make up a large share of the cost (its example is 75 percent). For those items, an agency should collect current local prices of labor, equipment and materials, and price the remaining items from bid history (FHWA 2021). The estimate classes this work feeds are explained in the AACE estimate classes guide.

Unbalanced bids: the federal definitions and the test owners apply

The federal rules name two kinds of unbalanced bid. A mathematically unbalanced bid is "a bid containing lump sum or unit bid items which do not reflect reasonable actual costs plus a reasonable proportionate share of the bidder's anticipated profit, overhead costs, and other indirect costs". A materially unbalanced bid is one that "generates a reasonable doubt that award to the bidder submitting a mathematically unbalanced bid will result in the lowest ultimate cost to the Federal Government" (23 CFR 635.102). After the opening, the DOT examines the apparent low bid's unit prices against the engineer's estimate and evaluates extreme variations or obvious unbalancing. A decision to award or reject over obvious unbalanced items needs written justification. A bid that is mathematically but not materially unbalanced may be awarded. For one that is both, FHWA's response ranges from concurring in a decision not to award to nonconcurrence or conditions limiting federal participation (635.114(c) to (e)). TxDOT rejects a contract whose low bid is mathematically and materially unbalanced, and that bidder may not bid the same contract again (Item 3, 3.1.2).

FHWA's guidelines explain how to read these definitions in practice. It is normal for contractors to carry overhead and profit in different items, usually those they expect not to be eliminated or to underrun. The owner's main concern is unbalancing "to take advantage of errors in the plans or specifications", along with early lump sum and unit items that would amount to an advance payment. The guidelines then cite a test from Wisconsin DOT. The reviewer flags significant items a set percentage above or below the estimate's unit price, checks those items for quantity errors and re-ranks the bidders at corrected quantities: "a change in the ranking is an indicator of a materially unbalanced bid" (FHWA 2021).

Quantities matter because of the contract's significant change clause. Under the federal-aid clause, a major item that grows past 125 percent or falls below 75 percent of its original quantity is a significant change. An increase is then adjusted only on the part above 125 percent, and a decrease on the work actually performed. A change that is not significant is paid as provided elsewhere in the contract (635.109(a)(3)), which for a unit price item usually means its bid price. TxDOT's version uses the same 25 percent and calls an item major when it reaches 5 percent of the original contract or $100,000, whichever is less (Items 1 and 4, 1.3.82 and 4.4). A plan quantity that an estimator believes is wrong is exactly what this test looks for.

Illustrative example, invented figures: four items, three bidders, one wrong quantity

An owner lets a small structure contract with its estimate published beside the bids. Bidder B is low by $12,500. An estimator at Bidder A, rechecking the borings and cross-sections, finds about 2,000 CY of rock where the plans show 500.

Invented letting: unit prices in dollars, the engineer's estimate first
ItemQuantityEstimateBidder ABidder BBidder C
0010 Mobilization1 LS250,000.00240,000.00235,000.00280,000.00
0020 Unclassified excavation20,000 CY18.0017.5015.0018.00
0030 Rock excavation500 CY95.0095.00300.00110.00
0040 Class A concrete, structures1,200 CY850.00840.00790.00860.00
Total at bid quantities1,677,5001,645,5001,633,0001,727,000
Total with rock at 2,000 CY1,820,0001,788,0002,083,0001,892,000
Invented letting: unit prices in dollars, the engineer's estimate first

With the threshold set at 30%, one price stands out. B's $300.00 for rock is 172.7% above the median of the three bids ($110.00) and 215.8% above the estimate ($95.00). B's other lines sit under the median, excavation by 14.3% and concrete by 6.0%. At bid quantities B totals $1,633,000 against A's $1,645,500. Each extra cubic yard of rock costs B $205 more than A, so B stays lowest only up to 500 + 12,500 / 205, about 561 CY. At 2,000 CY the order becomes A ($1,788,000), C ($1,892,000), B ($2,083,000). That is the ranking change FHWA's guidelines treat as the sign of a materially unbalanced bid.

Totals of the three invented bids as the rock excavation quantity changes$1.5M$1.7M$1.9M$2.1M05001,0001,5002,0002,500Rock excavation, CYPlan 500Your check 2,000Bidder ABidder BBidder CB stops being lowest at 561 CY
Every other quantity stays as bid. Where two lines cross, the ranking changes.

Whether the owner could reprice the overrun would depend on its significant change clause and on whether rock counts as a major item in that contract. The flag only tells the reviewer where to look.

The same checks for one contract of up to 200 items and five bidders: extended amounts, the low and median unit price of each line, each bid's deviation from the median and from the estimate, a flag past the threshold you set, totals and ranks, then totals and ranks again at the quantities you enter. Every cell starts empty, and the workbook recommends no threshold.

AASHTOWare Project and Bid Express, said accurately

The two names are easy to confuse, so here is what each one is. AASHTOWare Project is software that AASHTO licenses to transportation agencies, in modules that include Preconstruction, Estimation, Bids, Civil Rights & Labor, Construction & Materials and Data Analytics. Its Bids module exchanges data with Preconstruction or similar systems. It also lets contractors receive proposal item schedules and submit and withdraw item bids electronically (AASHTO). Bid Express is a different thing. It is an online service run by Infotech through which agencies advertise lettings and receive bids, and it launched in 1999 with Georgia DOT. Infotech's electronic bid system of 1992 became the basis of AASHTOWare Project Bids (Infotech).

In practice, Kentucky, Ohio, Louisiana and Virginia take bids through Bid Express, while Texas uses its own Electronic Bidding System (TxDOT). On the owner's side, VDOT's estimators price from AASHTOWare Project Estimation and the Statewide Bid Tab Query (VDOT manual, 4.4). LaDOTD's specifications page puts a note on changing an AASHTOWare Project spec book next to its 2026 edition, with a summary of item changes (LaDOTD). Keep in mind that the item numbers on a tab are the owner's, and they can change with a specification edition. VDOT's carry the spec year, and LaDOTD keeps its averages by spec year.

What a bid tab cannot tell you

Before you price from a tab, know what it does not record.

  • Prices, not costs. A tab shows what bidders asked in one letting, with overhead and profit placed where each chose (FHWA 2021). TxDOT lists quantity, season, traffic and competition among the factors that move them (5.4.1.3).
  • Bid quantities, not final quantities. Overruns, change orders and claims come later and are not on the tab.
  • Lump sums and nonstandard items hide scope. VDOT's manual shows an asbestos removal lump sum bid at $1 by one bidder, whose cost sat elsewhere in the bid (section 4.2).
  • Design-build and CM/GC. A design-build letting needs only a post-award tabulation of proposal prices, which may be lump sums. The tabulation rule does not apply to construction manager/general contractor (CM/GC) work at all (635.113(c) and (d)). Those projects therefore add little or no unit price history.
  • Thin samples. Some items have thousands of entries and others none (VDOT, 4.1.10). A rare item priced from two bids is a guess with a source.
  • Subcontractor quotes. Leveling the quotes you receive is a different job. The bid leveling template covers it.

Software can help with the mechanical part: reading tab PDFs into rows, matching pay items across spec editions, indexing prices and flagging lines against your own takeoff. That is close to the published OCBM work, where every quantity is tied to its source drawing (see the heavy civil page and the quantity takeoff guide). A person still decides which projects are comparable, whether a quantity is really wrong, and what to bid.

Questions readers ask

  • A bid tabulation, or bid tab, is the owner's record of the bids received at a letting. For each contract it lists every bidder's unit price and extended amount on every pay item, with the totals and, where the owner publishes it, the engineer's estimate. On federal-aid highway work, the state DOT must tabulate at least the item details of the three lowest acceptable bids and the totals of all others, certified by a responsible official (23 CFR 635.113(b)).

  • TxDOT's bid tabs are on its Bid Tabulations dashboard, and its average unit prices are on the Bid Item Averages dashboard, which replaced the old 3-month and 12-month average low bid unit price tables. The tabulations dashboard shows every bid and TxDOT's estimate for statewide and district lettings of the past 24 months, with an archive for tabs before January 2025. The averages dashboard covers 24 months by bid code and updates daily at 6:00 a.m.

  • A mathematically unbalanced bid has lump sum or unit prices that do not reflect reasonable actual costs plus a proportionate share of profit, overhead and indirect costs, and it becomes materially unbalanced when it raises a reasonable doubt that awarding it will give the lowest ultimate cost (23 CFR 635.102). The difference matters at award, because a bid that is only mathematically unbalanced may be awarded (635.114(d)).

  • No, AASHTOWare Project is AASHTO's licensed software for transportation agencies, while Bid Express is Infotech's online service through which many agencies advertise lettings and receive bids. AASHTOWare Project has modules for preconstruction, estimation, bids, civil rights and labor, construction and materials, and data analytics. KYTC, Ohio DOT, LaDOTD and VDOT take bids through Bid Express, while TxDOT uses its own Electronic Bidding System.

  • To bring an old unit price to today's dollars, multiply it by the ratio of the current value of a construction cost index to its value when the bid was placed. VDOT's Cost Estimating Manual names FHWA's National Highway Construction Cost Index (NHCCI) as the index to use for road and bridge work, not the consumer price index. It also notes that the index can fall as well as rise. FHWA's guidelines add that past inflation should not be projected into the future without a reason.

Sources and scope

Checked on . Every source was read on 9 November 2026. LaDOTD's websites refused automated requests that day, so its pages and the 2026 specifications were read from the Wayback Machine copies named in the labels. Item examples come from the owners' own files; the worked example is invented.

This guide explains public bidding records for educational purposes. It is not legal or bidding advice, and each owner's specifications, special provisions and proposal govern its own lettings.

Show us how your estimators read owner documents

Leave your work email, then pick a time for a 30-minute call on the owner documents your estimators read by hand, from plan sets and specifications to bid tabs. You leave with a written plan: what an agent could prepare and what stays with your team. No commitment.

We use your email to reply to you and, now and then, to tell you about Mirage. You can opt out at any time. Privacy policy