Non-conformance reports, drafted and followed to closure
Send us an inspection or test record with the specification and drawings it refers to. Mirage drafts the NCR, ties it to the clause and the drawing revision the work departs from, and follows the corrective action until your quality manager closes it.
ISO 9001 asks you to record the authority who decided each nonconformity and to check for similar ones elsewhere. On Virginia DOT design-build work, an item still active on the nonconformance log is not eligible for payment. Both depend on NCRs that cite the right clause and drawing revision, and on a log that someone reads across.
What a non-conformance report records
A non-conformance report (NCR) records work, material or design that does not meet a stated requirement, and what was decided about it. ISO 9001 splits the subject in two. Clause 8.7 deals with the output itself. You correct it; segregate, contain, return or suspend it; inform the customer; or obtain acceptance under concession. The clause also asks for a record of the nonconformity, the actions taken, any concession and the authority that decided. Clause 10.2 deals with the cause. You react, find out why it happened and whether similar nonconformities exist or could occur, then take corrective action and review whether it worked.
ISO published ISO 9001:2026 on 16 September 2026. Organizations certified to the 2015 edition have until 30 September 2029 to transition, and public summaries of the new edition keep both clause numbers. Because ISO sells the text of the standard, this page summarizes the two clauses from those public sources rather than quoting them.
Public owners add rules of their own. Virginia DOT's minimum quality requirements for design-build and P3 projects (July 2018) draw a line between two kinds of problem. A deficiency is nonconforming work that established means can correct, after which it complies, and it is kept in a deficiency log. A nonconformance is work that is not correctable, such as a safety or environmental permit violation, and it gets an NCR and goes in the nonconformance log. The distinction matters for payment. A deficiency with no corrective action plan agreed by the next application for payment becomes a nonconformance, and an item still active on the nonconformance log is not eligible for payment (section 5.13.4). Each NCR records the nonconformance and its date, with the documentation, evaluations and recommendations. It says how the work was separated, removed or tagged and gives any recommendation to repair or use as is. It also names the cause, the corrective action, who carries it out and the due date (section 5.14.1).
Use as is, repair, rework and reject follow the four verbs of federal nuclear quality rules. Those rules require nonconforming items to be "reviewed and accepted, rejected, repaired or reworked in accordance with documented procedures" (10 CFR 50, Appendix B, Criterion XV). In practice, your quality plan sets the list your project uses, and the contract sets who decides. On VDOT design-build work, for example, a use as is or repair disposition needs the Department project manager's review and acceptance, with the concurrence of the design-builder's design manager and quality assurance manager (5.14.1). A correction follows the design approved by the engineer of record and is then re-tested or re-inspected (5.13.4). The Department may also accept nonconforming work at a reduced price or with an extended warranty (5.15.2).
In the UK, the NEC4 Engineering and Construction Contract uses the term Defect instead. A Defect is a part of the works not in accordance with the Scope, or Contractor's design not in accordance with the applicable law or with the design the Project Manager accepted (clause 11.2(6)). The Supervisor and the Contractor notify Defects until the defects date (clause 43), the Contractor corrects them within the defect correction period (clause 44), and the Contractor or the Project Manager may propose changing the Scope so that a Defect is not corrected, against a quotation for reduced Prices, an earlier Completion Date or both, which the Project Manager may accept (clause 45; NEC's own summary). See NEC4 contract administration.
An NCR is not a punch list. An NCR is raised during the works, when an inspection or a test finds work that does not meet a requirement. A punch list comes later, at the walk-through before substantial completion. See the free punch list template for that one.
What Mirage does with an NCR
Drafts the NCR from the inspection record
Mirage reads the inspection report, test result or daily report entry and drafts the NCR. The draft says what was found and where, which specification clause applies, and which drawing and revision it concerns. Each field cites the line of the record it came from, and a drawing revision that is no longer current is flagged before the NCR goes out.
Proposes a disposition, a person decides
Mirage proposes a disposition from the list your quality plan uses. It then routes the NCR to your quality manager, and to the engineer of record or the owner where the contract gives them the decision. The agent never accepts, rejects or closes an NCR.
Finds repeats and follows corrective action to closure
Mirage compares each new NCR with the project's log, looking for the same defect, location, trade or supplier. It then follows each corrective action to its due date and to the re-inspection that closes it.
A log that shows repeats and stale revisions
An illustrative log: the project, references and values are invented.
| NCR | What was found | Spec clause | Drawing | Proposed disposition | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| NCR-021↳ Same defect as NCR-009 on level 1, same pour sequence: flagged as a repeat, and NCR-009's corrective action has no verification yet. | Slab thickness under tolerance, level 2, grid C-4 to D-5 | 03 30 00, 3.10 | S-201 rev. C | Repair, to the engineer of record | Open |
| NCR-022 | Anchor bolt projection short, column line 7 | 05 12 00, 3.4 | S-310 rev. B | Use as is, owner to accept | Awaiting disposition |
| NCR-023 | Joint sealant applied below the minimum temperature | 07 92 00, 3.3 | A-501 rev. D | Rework | Action in progress |
| NCR-024↳ The test report cites C-102 rev. A; rev. B was issued since. The revision is flagged for the quality manager before the NCR goes out. | Fill compaction test failed, lift 3, station 12+40 | 31 23 23, 3.6 | C-102 rev. A | Reject and replace | Open |
What goes in, what comes out
- Who uses it
- Quality managers, QA and QC inspectors and superintendents; the engineer of record and the owner for the dispositions the contract gives them.
- What goes in
- Inspection and test records, daily reports, site photos with their notes, the specification sections, the drawing register with current revisions, your quality plan's categories and dispositions, and your existing NCR log. Documents in English or French.
- What comes out
- A draft NCR with its clause, drawing and revision, a proposed disposition in your quality plan's words, the earlier NCRs it repeats, and the log updated with owner, due date and status.
- Where a person decides
- The quality manager issues every NCR and decides every disposition, unless the contract gives the decision to the engineer of record or the owner.
- What it does not do
- It does not accept, reject or close an NCR, sign anything, or replace the inspection itself.
- Where it runs
- In your cloud, on your premises or hosted by Mirage, with a named approver set for the workflow.
- How long it takes
- A reply within two business hours, a proof of concept one week after the first meeting, the first workflow in production in 4 to 6 weeks.
- How it is priced
- A fixed-price pilot first, then an annual subscription priced by volume, not per user.
Free NCR log (Excel)
The workbook has a register sheet with one row per NCR. Its columns are number, date raised, raised by, location, specification clause, drawing and revision, description, category, disposition, root cause, corrective action, action owner, due date, status, date closed, and days open, which is computed. A summary sheet counts NCRs by status, by category and by disposition. It also shows the open NCRs past their due date, the longest open and the average days to close.
Every cell is empty, so you type your quality plan's own categories. The four dispositions given (use as is, repair, rework, reject) follow the verbs of 10 CFR 50 Appendix B, Criterion XV, and are there for you to replace with yours.
What is published, and what is not
No Mirage deployment on non-conformance reports is published yet. The two construction deployments below are takeoff work, which is a different workflow. What they share with this one is that every output is tied back to the drawing it came from.
OCBM
3 agents in production
100% of quantities traceable to a source drawing
Workflow: quantity takeoff and bid pricing
John Cockerill
80 to 90% less time on piping takeoff
Fabrication bill of materials produced ten times faster
Workflow: piping takeoff and bill of materials
Send us an inspection record and the log it belongs to
We send back the drafted NCR with its clause, drawing and revision, and the earlier NCRs it repeats.
How a deployment runs: Observe, Map, Build, Run, Expand. See the method
Frequently asked questions
A non-conformance report records work, material or design that does not meet a stated requirement, and what was decided about it. It says what was found and where, which specification clause and drawing revision the work departs from, the disposition, the cause, the corrective action, and who owns it by when. An owner can also set what it contains: Virginia DOT's design-build quality requirements list the content field by field (section 5.14.1).
An NCR can have the dispositions your quality plan lists. Use as is, repair, rework and reject follow the four verbs of 10 CFR 50 Appendix B, Criterion XV, where nonconforming items are 'reviewed and accepted, rejected, repaired or reworked'. ISO 9001 clause 8.7 also allows acceptance under concession. An owner may also accept nonconforming work at a reduced price or with an extended warranty, as VDOT's requirements provide (section 5.15.2).
The disposition is decided by the person your contract and quality plan name. On VDOT design-build work, for example, a use as is or repair disposition needs the Department project manager's review and acceptance, with the concurrence of the design-builder's design manager and quality assurance manager. Mirage proposes a disposition, but it never accepts, rejects or closes an NCR.
An NCR and a punch list come at different times and do different jobs. An NCR is raised during the works, when an inspection or a test finds work that does not meet a requirement, and it carries a disposition and a corrective action. A punch list comes later, at the walk-through before substantial completion: it lists what is left to finish or fix before handover. Our free punch list template covers that second job.
ISO 9001 requires you to control each nonconforming output (clause 8.7) and to deal with its cause (clause 10.2). Under clause 8.7, you correct the output; segregate, contain, return or suspend it; inform the customer; or obtain acceptance under concession. You also keep a record of the nonconformity, the actions, any concession and who decided. Under clause 10.2, you react, find the cause, check whether similar nonconformities exist or could occur, take corrective action and review whether it worked. ISO 9001:2026 was published on 16 September 2026, and organizations certified to the 2015 edition have until 30 September 2029 to transition.
No Mirage deployment on non-conformance reports is published yet. The nearest published construction work is OCBM, with 3 agents in production and 100% of quantities traceable to a source drawing, and John Cockerill, with 80 to 90% less time on piping takeoff. Both are takeoff workflows, not NCRs.
A reply within two business hours, a proof of concept one week after the first meeting, the first workflow in production in 4 to 6 weeks.
It is priced as a fixed-price pilot first, then an annual subscription priced by volume, not per user.
Sources
Checked . Because ISO sells ISO 9001, its clauses are summarized from the public sources below, not quoted from the standard.
- ISO/TC 176/SC 2, ISO 9001:2026 has been released: publication of ISO 9001:2026 on 16 September 2026; organizations certified to ISO 9001:2015 have until 30 September 2029 to transition.
- ISO 9001 Checklist, 8.7 Control of Nonconforming Outputs (ISO 9001:2026 toolkit): the four ways of dealing with a nonconforming output, re-verification after correction, and the record to retain, including the authority that decided (public summary of clause 8.7).
- ISO Managed, ISO 9001 Clause 10.2 Nonconformity and Corrective Action: react, determine the cause and whether similar nonconformities exist or could occur, implement and review corrective action, retain the record (public summary of clause 10.2, 2026 edition).
- 10 CFR Part 50, Appendix B, Quality Assurance Criteria for Nuclear Power Plants and Fuel Reprocessing Plants (Code of Federal Regulations, 2025 edition, govinfo): Criterion XV: nonconforming items 'reviewed and accepted, rejected, repaired or reworked in accordance with documented procedures'; Criterion XVI: cause and corrective action for significant conditions adverse to quality.
- Virginia Department of Transportation, Minimum Requirements for Quality Assurance and Quality Control on Design Build and Public-Private Transportation Act Projects (July 2018): sections 5.13.4 (deficiency or nonconformance, payment), 5.14.1 (deficiency log, NCR content and log, use as is and repair dispositions), 5.15.1 and 5.15.2 (removal and replacement, acceptance at a reduced price or extended warranty).
- NEC, Defining and managing defects in ECC and liability for not correcting them (David Hunter, 19 June 2023): NEC4 ECC clauses 11.2(6), 43, 44 and 45.
FREE TEMPLATE