Project delivery methods for transit and bridge work: DBB, CM/GC, design-build, progressive design-build, P3 and alliance
Mirage Metrics wrote this guide for estimators and project directors bidding North American transit, bridge and highway work. A delivery method decides who designs, who builds, when the price is fixed and who carries the design and quantity risk. Design-bid-build finishes the design, then awards construction to the lowest responsive bid. Design-build prices design and construction together before the design is final. Construction manager/general contractor (CM/GC), called construction manager at risk in building work, hires the contractor during design. The price is then agreed package by package, checked against the owner's estimate or an independent cost estimate. Progressive design-build selects the team first and develops the design with it in a paid development phase, which leaves the owner free to contract the construction or not. Public-private partnership (P3) models add private finance and, in DBFM and DBFOM, decades of maintenance paid in instalments. An alliance shares the gap between actual cost and a target outturn cost.
- Published
- Updated
- Reading time
- 13 min
- Written by
- Jules Toussaint
This guide covers United States federal-aid highway rules (23 CFR Parts 635 and 636) and Ontario's models as Infrastructure Ontario states them. Its alliance terms come from Queensland Treasury's 2024 guidance. State statutes, transit grant rules and each solicitation vary. It is not legal advice.
Who wrote this, and why. Mirage Metrics builds AI agents that read construction documents. Each method hands the estimating team a different package at a different design maturity. The agent structures the takeoff quantities and keeps each one tied to the sheet it came from, and the estimator prices and decides. Mirage reads plan sets drawn in metric or imperial units, and documents in English or French. Skyway Bridging Partners, the progressive design-build team on Ontario's QEW Garden City Skyway, and Flatiron Dragados, Demathieu Bard Construction and Green Infrastructure Partners are among the companies Mirage is in production at. This page says nothing about that work. Mirage has published no case study on a delivery method. The nearest proofs are John Cockerill, 80 to 90% less time on piping takeoff, and OCBM, 100% of quantities tied to a source drawing. See the heavy civil page.
The delivery methods side by side
The table below sets the methods side by side, so you can see who carries what under each. The federal rules apply to federal-aid highway projects. The definitions of Infrastructure Ontario (IO), for their part, describe how Ontario's public owners use each model (IO, Delivery Models Overview, 2021).
| Method | Who designs and builds | When the price is fixed | Design and quantity risk | How the contractor is chosen | Where it is used | What the estimating team produces |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Design-bid-build (DBB) | Owner's designer, then a separate construction contract | At bid opening, on complete plans | Design: owner. Quantities: owner's on unit-price work, contractor's on a lump sum | Lowest responsive bid (635.114) | Federal-aid highway bid contracts; IO's smaller projects | A unit-price or lump-sum bid from complete plans |
| Design-build (DB) | One contract for both (636.103) | In the proposal, before final design | Design-builder, for its design and its quantities | Best value, or lowest price technically acceptable (636.210) | Federal-aid highways since 2002; IO and Metrolinx transit projects | A price on the team's own design quantities, often with ATCs |
| CM/GC, or construction manager at risk (CMAR) | Owner's designer; the contractor advises during design, then builds | Per package as the design advances (635.506(d)) | Design: owner. Price: contractor once agreed; above the GMP under CM@R | Qualifications, experience, best value or a stated mix (635.504(b)(5)) | Federal-aid highways since 2016; the MBTA's CM/GC manual | Estimates during design, then a price per package |
| Progressive design-build (PDB) | One team designs with the owner, then may build | End of the development phase; a target price in IO's model | Shared during development, then per the construction contract | A development partner chosen before design | QEW Garden City Skyway (IO and MTO, 2025); IO and Metrolinx transit projects | Estimates at each design step, then the construction price |
| Design-build-finance (DBF) | One consortium designs, builds and finances | Fixed in the bid; lump sum at substantial completion | Consortium, with the interest and penalties of delay | Competitive, among consortiums | IO: hospitals, courthouses, transportation | A construction estimate and the schedule that drives financing |
| DBFM and DBFOM | Project Co also maintains, rehabilitates and, in DBFOM, operates | Fixed in the bid; instalments over 20 to 30 years | Project Co, for performance over the term | Competitive, among consortiums | IO and Metrolinx transit (DBFOM); I-595 in Florida | Construction plus maintenance and rehabilitation over the term |
| Alliance | Owner, designer and contractor as one team | Target outturn cost, in the alliance development phase | Shared, design and construction included | Non-price selection, or two teams competing on the TOC | Union Station Enhancement Project (IO and Metrolinx) | The TOC, open book, then cost reports against it |
| Integrated project delivery (IPD) | Owner, architect, contractor and others in one process | Compensation tied to cost, schedule and profit milestones | Shared | By agreement | IO treats it as one model with alliance | Estimates shared with the design team |
Source: Federal rules: 23 CFR 635.114, Part 635, Subpart E, Part 636. Ontario: IO, 2021, IO model page, IO, 12 June 2025. I-595: FHWA. MBTA: FHWA's CM/GC page. Alliance: Queensland Treasury. IPD: AIA, 2007.
The design maturity at which a method fixes the price is what an estimate class measures. For the classes themselves, see the AACE estimate classes guide.
Design-bid-build and design-build under the federal rules
On a federal-aid highway project, the regulations define both methods and say how each contract is awarded. The federal rule defines design-bid-build as "the traditional project delivery method where design and construction are sequential steps" (23 CFR 636.103). A federal-aid contract let that way goes "only on the basis of the lowest responsive bid" from a responsible bidder, with the FHWA Division Administrator's concurrence (635.114).
A design-build contract "provides for design and construction of improvements by a contractor or private developer", and the term covers design-build-maintain, design-build-operate and design-build-finance contracts (636.103). FHWA "is neither requiring nor promoting" it (636.105). Award is on best value, which combines price and quality. On a modified design-build, where the owner furnishes partially complete plans, award can instead be on lowest price technically acceptable (636.103, 636.210).
Design-build vs design-bid-build for the bid team
For the bid team, the difference is where the quantities come from. Under design-bid-build, they come with the owner's complete plans, and on unit-price work with its bid schedule (see the DOT bid tabs guide). Under design-build, the request for proposals (RFP) asks for a technical and a price proposal (636.209(a)). The quantities then come from the team's own unfinished design, and their growth to the final design is the design-builder's.
Alternative technical concepts and stipends
The owner may accept alternative technical concepts (ATCs) that "provide an equal or better solution" and respect the environmental decision. It may do so if the RFP sets out their content, their review, any confidential meetings and their evaluation. ATCs stay confidential except as permitting requires (636.209(b), amended February 2014). A stipend to unsuccessful offerors, usually one-third to one-half of the estimated proposal cost, can buy the owner the right to use their ideas, unless State law forbids it (636.112, 636.113). So read that clause before you price an ATC.
CM/GC and CMAR: the two-phase contract and the independent cost estimate
The method goes by more than one name, but the structure is the same. FHWA's term is CM/GC, regulated for federal-aid projects since December 2016 (23 CFR Part 635, Subpart E). Infrastructure Ontario calls the structure construction management at risk. FHWA's own CM/GC page lists NCHRP Synthesis 402, "Construction Manager-at-Risk Project Delivery for Highway Programs" (FHWA). Construction manager vs general contractor is not a choice: the same firm is first one, then the other.
The contract has two phases (635.504(a)). The first covers preconstruction services: scheduling, sequencing, cost engineering, constructability, cost estimating and risk identification, but not design (635.502). The second is construction, as one contract or several packages, early work packages included. Selection may rest on qualifications, experience, best value or a stated mix (635.504(b)(5)). The contractor must self-perform at least 30 percent of the construction cost, specialty work excluded (635.504(d)).
How the price is agreed, and the off-ramp
FHWA approves a price estimate for the whole project before construction is authorized. For each package, the owner compares the agreed price with its engineer's estimate or an independent cost estimate (ICE), "if required by the contracting agency", and FHWA approves both (635.506(d)). In FHWA's words, if the owner, the designer and the independent cost estimator agree the price is fair, the owner issues the construction contract (FHWA). So at every agreement, two estimates of the same package meet: the contractor's and the owner's.
Agreement can fail, and the rule provides an off-ramp. If the owner is "unwilling or unable" to contract the construction with the CM/GC, it may procure it another way with FHWA's concurrence. It may also bar the CM/GC from bidding (635.504(b)(6)). Under CM@R in Ontario, the price is a guaranteed maximum price (GMP), and overruns above it are the contractor's. Because the GMP is set before the design is complete, it is "likely to include a risk premium" (IO, 2021). Transit owners use the method too: FHWA lists the Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority's CM/GC procurement manual (FHWA).
Where the environmental review sits on a US federal-aid project
On a federal-aid project, the environmental review under the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) sets how early each method engages the contractor. A design-build owner may issue the request for qualifications (RFQ), and even the RFP, before the review ends. It may do so if it states the review's status and commits to no alternative, no-build included. It may also award and allow preliminary design, but final design and construction wait for the decision (23 CFR 636.109).
A CM/GC owner may award before NEPA for preconstruction services, with an option for construction. But no construction, early work packages included, may start before the review ends, even at risk. Final design before then is at the agency's own expense, without federal funds (635.505).
Progressive design-build: development phase, price and off-ramp
Progressive design-build chooses the team first and settles the price later. Infrastructure Ontario's progressive design-build "works collaboratively to develop design, reduce risk and finalize pricing before contracting for implementation" (IO). It "employs a target-price similar to a traditional Design-Build model, rather than the fixed price enabled under a P3 model", and IO and Metrolinx use it on select transit projects (IO, 2021).
On 12 June 2025, IO and the Ministry of Transportation (MTO) announced a Development Phase Agreement with Skyway Bridging Partners for the QEW Garden City Skyway twinning, an approximately 2.2 km twin bridge across the Welland Canal. During the phase, of about 19 months, the parties "work together to progress the design, risk, cost and schedule". At its end, IO and MTO "will have the option to enter into a contract for the construction" (IO, 12 June 2025). That option is the off-ramp.
A progressive P3 (progressive DBF or DBFM) follows the same sequence before a final fixed price. Affordability caps and alternate prices let the owner choose how much scope to buy (IO, 2021), and the owner makes monthly payments during development (IO model page).
On a US federal-aid highway project
Part 636 does not name progressive design-build. Its nearest mechanism is a design-build contract awarded before NEPA concludes. In that case, the owner need not evaluate the total price and may award on qualitative grounds. Final design and construction then wait for a finding of price reasonableness, with FHWA's concurrence. That finding is based on competitive procurement, an open-book negotiated price or an independent estimate of similar work (636.302(a)(1), amended August 2007). For buildings, the American Institute of Architects (AIA) publishes a progressive design-build agreement: see the AIA contract documents guide.
Progressive design-build vs design-build
In design-build the team commits to a price on a design it has barely started. In progressive design-build the price follows a development phase the owner pays for and joins, and the owner can still walk away. So the estimating output becomes a sequence of estimates, then the construction price.
P3 models: DBF, DBFM, DBFOM and availability payments
P3 models add private finance to design-build, and some add decades of maintenance. In a design-build-finance (DBF) contract, the consortium finances construction. "A lump-sum payment at substantial completion" pays off design, construction and financing, so delay costs the consortium interest and penalties. In a design-build-finance-maintain (DBFM) contract, Project Co, the consortium's project company, also maintains and rehabilitates the asset to performance specifications for typically 20 to 30 years, and is paid in instalments. The public keeps ownership. A design-build-finance-operate-maintain (DBFOM) contract adds operations, and IO and Metrolinx have used it for some transit projects (IO, 2021).
On Florida's I-595, a 35-year DBFOM, the Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT) pays final acceptance payments of $686 million (year of expenditure). It also pays availability payments capped by an annual maximum of $65.9 million in 2009 dollars, and it keeps the toll revenue (FHWA project profile). In a revenue risk concession, by contrast, the partner is paid from user charges. IO has no project on that model (IO, 2021). Because the price covers decades of maintenance, the project agreement decides what it includes. For what to check in one, see the P3 project agreement review guide.
Alliance, target outturn cost and IPD
In an alliance, the owner shares design and construction risk with its partners. They are paid in three parts: their actual direct costs, a fee for profit and corporate overhead, and a pre-agreed share of the "pain or gain" from actual against target performance. The agreement is no-disputes, best-for-project and open book, and the owner sits on every alliance team (Queensland Treasury, 2024).
The target outturn cost (TOC) comes first. After a non-price selection, an Alliance Development Agreement covers the design and construction solutions and the TOC. In a price-competitive selection, two teams develop TOCs in parallel. Queensland points alliances at unclear scope and large risks outside the owner's control (Queensland Treasury). IO and Metrolinx adopted an alliance for the Union Station Enhancement Project (IO, 2021). In Québec, collaborative modes come under Loi 62: see the guide to Loi 62 (in French).
The AIA defines integrated project delivery (IPD) as integrating "people, systems, business structures and practices into a process that collaboratively harnesses the talents and insights of all participants" (AIA, 2007). IO treats IPD and alliance as one model, with compensation "directly tied to cost, schedule and profitability milestones of the overall project" (IO, 2021). The AIA's IPD agreements are listed in the AIA contract documents guide.
When not to use each method
Each method also has cases where it fits badly. These are the ones to watch for.
- Design-bid-build, when construction must start before the design is done, or when the owner wants the builder's methods inside the design. The method makes design and construction sequential.
- Design-build, when the owner wants contractor input on the concept itself. By the UK Highways Agency's estimate, a design-build design is at least 80 percent constrained, which is why the Agency moved to early contractor involvement (FHWA scan, 2005).
- CM/GC, when the owner cannot staff a price analysis for every package, or needs price competition at award. The price is negotiated with one firm, and the off-ramp exists because agreement can fail.
- Progressive design-build, when the owner cannot commit its people to a development phase of a year or more, or needs a fixed price at selection.
- DBF, DBFM, DBFOM, when maintenance cannot be written as performance over 20 to 30 years, or the owner cannot fund instalments over that term.
- Alliance and IPD, when the scope is clear and the risks are priced. Queensland's conditions for an alliance are the opposite, and the owner must sit on every alliance team.
Check the owner's authority too. FHWA's CM/GC page lists state enabling laws, among them Connecticut's Public Act 12-70, Nevada's public works chapter 338 and Washington's RCW 39.10 (FHWA).
North American delivery terms, defined
If a term in a solicitation is new to you, start here. Each definition below comes from the source named beside it.
| Term | Definition | Source |
|---|---|---|
| DBB, design-bid-build | Design and construction happen as sequential steps, under separate contracts. | 23 CFR 636.103 |
| DB, design-build | One agreement covers design and construction. The federal term also includes design-build with maintenance, operation or finance added. | 23 CFR 636.103 |
| CMAR, construction manager at risk | The contractor gives preconstruction advice, then builds at cost plus fee under a guaranteed maximum price. | IO 2021 |
| CM/GC (CMGC) | A two-phase contract: the contractor provides preconstruction services during design, then builds if a price is agreed. | 23 CFR 635.502 |
| Preconstruction services | These are scheduling, sequencing, cost engineering, constructability, cost estimating and risk identification. They do not include design. | 23 CFR 635.502 |
| Early work package | Part of the construction is bought after NEPA and before the design is complete, once its scope can be priced. | 23 CFR 635.502 |
| PDB, progressive design-build | The owner and its partner develop the design, reduce risk and finalize pricing before contracting for implementation. | IO model page |
| Development phase | In this paid period, the owner and its partner progress the design, risk, cost and schedule. | IO, June 2025 |
| Off-ramp | The owner may decline to award construction to the phase-one team and procure it another way. | 23 CFR 635.504(b)(6) |
| GMP, guaranteed maximum price | This is the CMAR ceiling: construction cost overruns above it are the contractor's. | IO 2021 |
| ICE, independent cost estimate | The owner makes its own estimate, and when the agency requires one, a CM/GC price is analysed against it. | 23 CFR 635.506(d)(3) |
| ATC, alternative technical concept | A proposer offers a departure from the RFP that is equal or better, and the owner may allow it at its discretion. | 23 CFR 636.209(b) |
| ECI, early contractor involvement | In the UK Highways Agency's model, teams are chosen early on qualifications, and an open book target price follows. | FHWA scan, 2005 |
| DBF | The private partner designs and builds, finances construction, and is repaid at substantial completion. | IO 2021 |
| DBFM | A DBFM adds maintenance and rehabilitation for 20 to 30 years to a DBF, paid in instalments. | IO 2021 |
| DBFOM | A DBFOM adds operations to a DBFM, under the same contract. | IO 2021 |
| Availability payment | The owner pays periodically over a P3's term, instead of paying at completion. | FHWA, I-595 |
| Alliance | The owner and its partners share risk and reward under a no-disputes, open book agreement, and make best-for-project decisions. | Queensland Treasury |
| TOC, target outturn cost | This is the alliance's cost target, and actual cost measured against it sets the shared pain or gain. | Queensland Treasury |
| IPD, integrated project delivery | This approach integrates people, systems, business structures and practices through design, fabrication and construction. | AIA, 2007 |
Questions readers ask
The difference is that design-bid-build runs design and construction in sequence under separate contracts, while design-build puts both in one contract, priced before final design. Under design-bid-build, the owner's designer completes the plans, then construction goes to the lowest responsive bid (23 CFR 635.114 on federal-aid highways). Under design-build, the contractor is selected on best value or lowest price technically acceptable (23 CFR Part 636).
Progressive design-build is a method in which the owner chooses its partner before the design, develops design, risk, cost and schedule with it in a paid development phase, then decides whether to contract the construction with that team. Infrastructure Ontario's model ends in a target price, not a P3's fixed price. On the QEW Garden City Skyway, the phase was expected to take about 19 months.
CMAR and CM/GC do not differ in structure: in both, the contractor is hired during design for preconstruction services, then builds once a price is agreed. CM/GC is FHWA's term for highway work (23 CFR Part 635, Subpart E). Construction manager at risk is the usual building term, and Infrastructure Ontario pairs it with a guaranteed maximum price.
An independent cost estimate in CM/GC is the owner's own estimate of a construction package, independent of the CM/GC contractor, used to judge whether its price is fair. The federal rule compares the agreed price with the engineer's estimate or an ICE when the agency requires one. FHWA approves the price before construction is authorized.
The difference between DBFM and DBFOM is operations. In a DBFM, the consortium designs, builds, finances, maintains and rehabilitates the asset for typically 20 to 30 years, and is paid in instalments. In a DBFOM, it also runs the asset, as on a light rail line. Infrastructure Ontario and Metrolinx have used DBFOM for some transit projects.
Sources and scope
Checked on . All sources were read on 9 November 2026; the eCFR text is the version current at 1 November 2026. Owners' documents describe their own programmes; a solicitation's terms govern a given bid.
- 23 CFR Part 635, Subpart E, Construction Manager/General Contractor (CM/GC) Contracting (81 FR 86943, December 2, 2016), current eCFR text: 635.502 definitions (CM/GC contractor, preconstruction services, early work package); 635.504(a) two phases, (b)(5) selection, (b)(6) new procurement if no agreement, (d) 30 percent self-performance; 635.505 NEPA; 635.506(d)(2) to (4) price estimate, price analysis against the engineer's estimate or an ICE, approval
- 23 CFR 635.114, Award of contract and concurrence in award, current eCFR text: award only on the lowest responsive bid from a responsible bidder; Division Administrator's concurrence
- 23 CFR Part 636, Design-Build Contracting (67 FR 75926, December 10, 2002, as amended), current eCFR text: 636.103 definitions; 636.105 optional; 636.109 NEPA; 636.112 and 636.113 stipends; 636.209(a) and (b) proposals and ATCs (79 FR 8266, February 12, 2014); 636.210 lowest price technically acceptable; 636.302(a)(1) award before NEPA and price reasonableness (72 FR 45338, August 14, 2007); no mention of progressive design-build
- FHWA, Construction Manager/General Contractor (CM/GC), Contract Administration program page, updated April 10, 2025: the two phases and the independent cost estimator's role in the price; the MBTA's CM/GC procurement manual; NCHRP Synthesis 402; state enabling legislation
- Infrastructure Ontario, Choosing the Right Model for Each Project (web page, read 9 November 2026): progressive design-build finalizes pricing before contracting for implementation; monthly owner payments in a progressive P3's development phase
- Infrastructure Ontario, Procurement and Delivery Model Selection Process: Delivery Models Overview, September 2021: DBB, DB, IPD/Alliance (Union Station Enhancement Project), CM@R and its GMP, DBF, DBFM (20 to 30 years, instalments), DBFOM, progressive DBF/DBFM, progressive design-build (target price), revenue risk concession
- Infrastructure Ontario, Development Phase Agreement executed for the QEW Garden City Skyway, June 12, 2025: Development Phase Agreement under progressive design-build; about 19 months; IO and MTO's option to contract construction; 2.2 km twin bridge across the Welland Canal
- FHWA Center for Innovative Finance Support, Project Profile: I-595 Corridor Roadway Improvements (read 9 November 2026): DBFOM for a 35-year term; final acceptance payments and availability payments; FDOT sets the tolls and keeps the toll revenue
- Queensland Treasury, Project Assessment Framework: Alliance establishment and management, August 2024: three-limb remuneration, pain and gain against targets, no disputes, best for project, open book, owner on every alliance team, shared design and construction risk; TOC in the Alliance Development Agreement phase or from two competing teams; when an alliance fits
- The American Institute of Architects and AIA California Council, Integrated Project Delivery: A Guide, version 1, 2007: definition of integrated project delivery
- FHWA Office of International Programs, Construction Management Practices in Canada and Europe (international scanning study, 2005), chapter 2, Project Delivery: the UK Highways Agency's early contractor involvement: early qualifications-based selection, open book target pricing; a design-build design at least 80 percent constrained, by the Agency's estimate
This guide explains public procurement practice for educational purposes. It is not legal advice and does not replace a reading of the solicitation and contract by a qualified professional.
Show us how your estimating team reads bid documents
Leave your work email, then pick a time for a 30-minute call on the delivery method your next pursuit runs under and the documents your estimating team reads by hand. You leave with a written plan: what an agent could prepare and what stays with your team. No commitment.